Tony: I got m We guide our loyal readers to some of the best products, latest trends, and most engaging stories with non-stop coverage, available across all major news platforms. Chris Smith has been covering consumer electronics ever since the iPhone revolutionized the industry in 2008. It almost killed him. The lighting briefly changes after the Hulk's snap, in the scene where the Hulk looks at the birds in the tree, indicating that this additional dust has been extracted from the atmosphere again. What do you do with graduate students who don't want to work, sit around talk all day, and are negative such that others don't want to be there? Marvel has provided more evidence that Thanos is still alive after the events ofAvengers: Endgame. Is it that hard to conceive that these stones couldn't use there own intelligence to see what Tony had saw and been threw to lock Thanos into one of these "inevitable" loops. Published May 22, 2019 A subtle detail in Avengers: Infinity War hints that the snap didn't really kill anyone at all - and implies that Thanos isn't dead. Why did Iron Man have to die? part of the Terran army, but apart from that, given his pretty strong will to survive, was there an immediate reason for him to go for the snap right then and there? At the beginning of Avengers: Endgame, the remaining heroes from the Guardians and the Avengers seek out Thanos on a world known as the Garden, a place Nebula said was the constant destination her father always discussed once his plan was complete. The theory seems daring, and I have to say that it would undoubtedly fit Marvels misleading ways, but there are also plenty of holes. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The Marvel Cinematic Universe reached its peak with Avengers: Infinity War, which brought together all the current superheroes to stop Thanos from collecting all the Infinity Stones, and Avengers: Endgame, where the surviving heroes reversed the snap and defeated the Mad Titan once and for all. What's the difference between Hulk's snap and Tony's then? Spoilers are allowed but please tag them as such. And even if they did run off, where to? Why can C not be lexed without resolving identifiers? - MichaelF May 14, 2019 at 0:42 4 InStar Trek, a transporter converts a person or object on a molecular level, transforming them into an energy pattern. BGR is a part of Penske Media Corporation. rev2023.6.29.43520. That's minor compared to universe level, it wasn't even city level. The Time Stone has specific constraints, and those force us to interpret the various snaps ofAvengers: Infinity War andAvengers: Endgame in a way they probably weren't intended to be interpreted. The climax of Avengers: Infinity War does not go the way fans originally thought. @Valorum I edited to add evidence. Speaking to Rotten Tomatoes (via CBR), directors Anthony and Joe Russo explained how they decided to have the victims of the snap turn to dust. And after each one, there's always another, and they all lead here, but never further." As Thanos departs to retrieve the sixth and final Stone, Stark asks Strange why he made that choice, and the answer is interesting. Matthew Macfadyen's big role in Deadpool 3 might have leaked, Secret Invasion finally fixes the lingering Avengers plot hole after Endgame, Im a longtime Mac user, but Im so jealous of Windows 11s ChatGPT Copilot, Silo on Apple TV+ offers a master class in world-building and sci-fi storytelling, The top-rated Netflix original series, ranked by Rotten Tomatoes, Apple gave us a first look at Invasion season 2 before its August 23 release, The best underrated Netflix series and hidden gems to watch right now, James Webb spots first starlight from ancient quasars in mind-blowing discovery, WhatsApp launches Chat Transfer feature between same operating systems, Heres why Google thinks its Gemini AI will surpass ChatGPT, Astronomers found a planet that shouldnt exist. 17 17 comments Top Add a Comment cpancoast 1 yr. ago Thanos didn't come back- he came from the past. Larger ships (which we saw) and larger energy signatures from the readings of those ships. This would also show why Thanos is different between the two movies, in the first movie Thanos is a lot calmer and more malevolent in his persueit of the stones almost like he knows he would collect them whereas the Thanos we see from 2014 in Endgame is more aggressive in his nature to get the stones due to the fact that's all he knows and is unaware of his success, again if he had been sent back to his original timeline knowing of his success and then death, that could be why he had no defences surrounding the planet (the garden) that he rested on and almost greeted the avengers and his own death as an old friend that was inevitable. It took the power of the Infinity Gauntlet to undo Thanos' snap, but it might be easier to reverse Tony Stark's. After all, Thanos affected the entire universe, whereas Tony's was geographically limited and erased a far smaller number of beings and objects from existence. A second comment, from executive producer Trinh Tran, supports the idea that Tony Stark's Thanos-destroying snap is a mirror-image ofAvengers: Infinity War. Avengers: Infinity War saw Thanos wiping out half of all life in the universe with the snap of his fingers, with various heroes turning into dust but why exactly did they disappear like that instead of dying? murdered) in order to gain one of the infinity stones and enact his plan. The place to drop your theories and memes about the MCU. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Turning the heroes to dust also added to the drama of the scene, as they didnt vanish right away nor at the same time, which is why the surviving ones saw their friends and family disappear right in front of them. But it also sounds like Thanos may not be his formidable selfthe Snap may have taken a serious physical toll on him, so its possible hes more easily dispatched when the OG Avengers finally catch up to him. He swiped left on Death. Marvel has punked us all, Reddit user Knight3rrant explains. In reality, Thanos' snap doesn't make sense at all. The Blip (also known as the Decimation and the Snap) is a major fictional event depicted in the Marvel Cinematic Universe franchise in which half of all living things in the universe, chosen at random, were exterminated by Thanos snapping his fingers while wearing the Infinity Gauntlet and wielding the Infinity Stones in 2018, and then restored . Cookie Notice By this logic, nobody was truly killed when Thanos snapped his fingers; instead, they were shunted into a sort of cosmic cold storage, where they were held in stasis. The post-credits scene (see it above) that shows the conversation between Maria Hill and Fury seems to indicate that people turned to dust long before the snap even happened: We see this. Question: Why did Tony stark choose to die when he could have defeated thanos without sacrificing his life? I get that his sacrifice might have saved a (small?) Logically, if a person using the Time Stone can't see past their own death, but Doctor Strange could see all the futures that flowed from the snap, it must mean the snap didn't kill people at all. BGRs audience craves our industry-leading insights on the latest in tech and entertainment, as well as our authoritative and expansive reviews. But those stones all come from different universes and they wont work exactly as advertised when used together. The real ones are with the Avengers. Thanos already had four of the six Infinity Stones he needed to complete the Gauntlet, sacrificing his daughter in the process. How to describe a scene that a small creature chop a large creature's head off? Joe Russo shared that they thought about the elemental aspect of your body and what happens to it, so the vanishing was a way of accelerating the decomposing process. If he had not made that decision, had he gone for the kill, they wouldnt be in this situation. Everything I've read, people seem to think that Tony just disappeared them, like Thanos originally did to half of everyone else. Why does Tony have to snap Thanos and his army to death, wouldn't that create a massive paradox in the timeline because then the original snap wouldn't have happened and cause massive parallel timelines like the ancient one said it wouldSo why couldn't have Tony snapped Thanos back to original point in time with the knowledge that it will a. The last piece of evidence centers around one of Thanos' other children. He's been working for Collider for over a decade, and in addition to managing content also runs point on crafts interviews, awards coverage, and co-hosts The Collider Podcast with Matt Goldberg (which has been running since 2012). Speaking at San Diego Comic-Con 2019, the writers of Avengers: Endgame have confirmed that Gamora survived Tony Stark's snap. Cookie Notice Tony would have to sacrifice his life, to miss out on his daughter's future. Didn't they run around with the Gauntlet and Thanos was still able to get it? @DJClayworth He knows it's going to hurt him a lot, I doubt he was aware it was 100% going to kill him even if he might suspect. He did not dedicate any thought to who lived and who died; he simply snapped his fingers and let the chaos of probability determine the grisly details. How could submarines be put underneath very thick glaciers with (relatively) low technology? Related: Avengers: Age of Ultron Foreshadowed Thor's Infinity War Failure. When Strange lived through the 14 million branching timelines of Infinity War, the only one he saw where Thanos was defeated was the one where Tony sacrificed himself using the Iron Gauntlet to turn Thanos and his forces to ashes. The way the heroes vanished in Avengers: Infinity War wasnt just made that way to make the audience cry theres a lot more to it, both in-universe and behind the scenes. Then again, the Avengers cant save everyone, and previous films are a testament to that. Many have theorized that the Thanos Snap didnt kill half the universes population but instead trapped them all inside the Soul Stone, which would mean that Avengers 4 would find the heroes trying to venture inside the stone to get them out. Now that you know the end, go back and watch that moment. One subtle detail, however, suggests that may not be the case at all - and it has important implications for the end ofAvengers: Endgame. In the three-hour span of "Endgame," the Avengers confront and kill Thanos (Josh Brolin), who had used the Infinity Gauntlet to snap away half of all life in the universe. Strange calls out and tells Thanos that he will give him the Time Stone if he spares Tony's life. But how exactly did the snap work? Even if the snap has been faked to mess with Thanos and ultimately beat him, some people will die, Avengers included. What Thanos did was more like willing people out of existence rather than killing them, which is why it was possible for them to return, but Black Widow and Vision couldnt be brought back as they truly died prior to the snap. Let's try to reconstruct what actually happened with the snap. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. The heroes that vanished as a result of Thanos' snap in Avengers: Infinity War turned to dust, but why did they vanish like that? When hes not writing about the most recent tech news for BGR, he brings his entertainment expertise to Marvels Cinematic Universe and other blockbuster franchises. Fearless, loyal and tough as nails. Although a couple of years passed since the snap that turned half the universe into dust, the consequences of this could still be felt, and they will surely continue to have an impact in upcoming films. Some theories say Fury knew all along to expect the snap and thats precisely why he never summoned Captain Marvel before then. Its likely similar things happened everywhere on Earth and other planets, meaning that people who have survived the snap may have been killed in the accidents the snap caused. He believed he fought on the side of life, but in truth he was a champion of death. Traditional blockbuster storytelling would dictate that the heroes win and the villain is defeated, but what if the villain is the main character of your movie? For more information, please see our Even if he didn't kill him then, there would've been a 50/50 chance that Tony died in the Snap, and then all the variables that would've applied after that, with other combinations of deaths that heightened or lessened the threat to Thanos. The fact thatStephen Strange could see behind the snap, when according to Doctor Strangea sorcerer cannot see beyond death, supports the idea that the snaps didn't really kill at all;the same theoryis also supported by a deleted scene fromAvengers: Endgame, in which the Ancient One said the Infinity Stones could not reverse death - but can still undo the snap. It only takes a minute to sign up. How could the dustings from that scene happen an hour (or more) before the Snap? Because it means Thanos and his armies aren't really dead at all. That fits perfectly with the idea that a massive amount of dust particles have been introduced into the atmosphere, and are preventing some of the sun's radiation reaching the planet. Amazingly, they can execute it to perfection until Quill realizes Gamora's fate. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Well, movies that involved time traveling can be complex like that. Thor makes that choice when he plunges the axe into Thanos chest because he wants to tell him that he got him, that this is payback. It may have taken time and a lot of death, but at some point, Thanos would have gotten the Time Stone anyway; otherwise, there wouldn't have been 14 million futures where they lost in Infinity War. She reveals Thanos' main goal is "to wipe out half the universe . It was do or die at that moment as Thanos has just shrugged all of them off. How did Tony Stark have the Mark II armour in Iron Man 3? Strange agrees to give the Time Stone. His reasoning is simple: on a planet with too many people and limited resources, the survivors have more than they need, solving the world's problems. Later, just before Dr. The Avengers had just had a desperate fight with Thanos over the Gauntlet in which Thanos won, Tony just sneakily beat him. Meanwhile, the fake stones do have certain powers, but theyre nothing like the real ones: My pet theory regarding how they foil Thanos is by going back in time to gather the MCU universes native Infinity Stones with Infinity Stones while substituting each with Stones borrowed from other universes, so the out of phase substituted Stones from six different universes will fizzle when used together. It took the power of the Infinity Gauntlet to undo Thanos' snap, but it might be easier to reverse Tony Stark's. It had already been established that the Gauntlet can allow for all manner of nuance. You can reverse that." The problem was that Paulie was no longer a . There was no second wave of ships. Todays deals: $4.50 smart plugs, $100 off AirPods Max, $65 smart TV, GE Opal ice makers, more. "I've spent so many years peering through time," the Ancient One told Stephen Strange, "I've prevented countless terrible futures. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. I felt like at that moment when Strange lifts up his finger Tony finally got it. Update crontab rules without overwriting or duplicating. This being giving Thanos the Time Stone. There's a practical reason why no one else could've done the final snap in Avengers: Endgame other than Iron Man. [caption id="attachment_705270" align="aligncenter" width="600"], The Russo Brothers Explain Why Scarlet Witch Lost Her Accent in 'Infinity War', Infinity War Directors on Why Those Trailer Scenes Arent in the Movie, Avengers: Infinity War Actor Hints that [Spoiler] Is Really Dead and Gone. Although he's now dedicated to Star Wars content, he's a lifelong fan of several other major franchises including Doctor Who and Marvel. All Rights Reserved. That bit of honor proved to be his undoing. What's the difference between Hulk's snap and Tony's then? The only problem with his plan is that, according to Thanos, the beauty of his vision was that it was inherently random. Strange uses the Time Stone to see like a lot of possibilities (don't remember exact number) and says that, in only one of them do the Avengers win. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Thats where directors Joe and Anthony Russo decided to take Infinity War, which culminates in Thanos gaining all six infinity stones, snapping his fingers, and wiping out half the population of the entire universe. The way the bodies turned to ashes was also carefully planned to add more drama to each fallen heroes final moments for example, Grootwas reaching out to Rocket, but as legs and arms vanished first, Rocket could never hold his hand. Well find out a year from now when Avengers 4 hits theaters. It's entirely possible that, somewhere in the depths of space, some alien races studied into the science behind the snap and worked out what had happened - even managing to reverse it. New framing occasionally makes loud popping sound when walking upstairs, Is there and science or consensus or theory about whether a black or a white visor is better for cycling? only living things were dusted. RELATED: Every Marvel Cinematic Universe Phase 4 Movie So Far, Ranked by Critic. Tom Bacon is Head of Screen Rant's Star Wars coverage. comments One of the conditions of Tony's involvement in the Time Heist was that when they recovered all six Stones from the various timelines, there would be no alteration of the past five years so that his daughter's life would be protected. For all he knew he was going to be heavily injured but survive it. Joe Russo confirmed that what we see inside the stone is indeed Gamoras spirit, while also deftly changing the topic of conversation to the damage the Thanos Snap did to Thanos himself: I think its a reflection of [Gamoras] spirit, and the power required to use all of the stones at once is so significant that it sends Thanos into this dream state. That's why, when the Hulk snapped his fingers, people returned exactly as they were; their clothes reformed as well, the things they had in their pockets, even items as esoteric as Bucky's cybernetic arm or Falcon's wings. It was also established that one could single out one person in the casting, as the Hulk described when he tried to bring Natasha back. Next:Every Upcoming Marvel Cinematic Universe Movie. Now, Marvel has further fuelled fan speculation with the publication ofThe Art of Marvel Studios' Avengers: Endgame, a book of concept art and exclusive interviews, which contains two important clues regarding what happened to Thanos at the end of Endgame. He could not have given it to Thor or anyone else that might have survived snapping the gauntlet because they didn't get it. 91 So in other words, you're asking "Why is Gamora?" - rickster May 13, 2019 at 19:27 5 Remember that the only reason they never got the Gauntlet off on Titan was due to Quill sorting out his relationship problems with Thanos. In Avengers: Infinity War, Doctor Strange doesn't seem to get nearly enough credit for how he engineered the one option out of millions to save the lives of half the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Dr. His insane "solution" was to kill off half of all living things in the cosmos. Can you back this up with any evidence? Scan this QR code to download the app now. Honest news coverage, reviews, and opinions since 2006. Even if it would have taken him an additional 5 years it would not matter cause they are time jumping. Marvel has punked us all, Reddit user Knight3rrant explains. Is there any evidence to indicate that the goal of the snap has any impact on the result of using all the stones at once? And that logically raises the possibility that Thanos could return. [He takes a good look at the gauntlet] It's likeI was made for this.'. The theory suggests that beating Thanos is only possible by not interfering with his original plan and making sure he has all the Infinity Stones at his disposal. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. The important part of this insight, however, is that if Thanos always kept his word, then when he performed the Snap, he likely did indeed exempt Tony from it specifically since he had told Strange that he would spare Tony's life. They never had time to think about it once 2013 Thanos attacked the compound- they just fought. Avengers: Endgame didn't so much as hint as to what happened to these souls; all that can be said for sure is that, for Peter Parker, there was no awareness of the passage of time. Australia to west & east coast US: which order is better? The only way this works is if Tony dies. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Thanos more than likely saved Tony, and in doing so, in disrupting the gospel of chaos he had always espoused, Thanos doomed himself, and Strange was the architect of the whole thing. Why risk it? It was the winning outcome as well. In the movie scene, it seems to me that at the point when Tony snatches the stones off of Thanos' gauntlet, the situation was pretty much in control already. Maria updates Nick with the latest intel. As a soldier, Paulie was second to none. What Exactly did Tony's snap do Everything I have been reading makes me confused about what Tony did. He's heavily involved with his local church, and anyone who checks him out on Twitter will swiftly learn he's into British politics too. But the radiation's mostly gamma. What's the meaning (qualifications) of "machine" in GPL's "machine-readable source code"? Why do CRT TVs need a HSYNC pulse in signal? Everything I've read, people seem to think that Tony just disappeared them, like Thanos originally did to half of everyone else. It may have taken time and a lot of death, but at some point, Thanos . And also Bruce is only guessing it will kill them, none of them know for sure; they are only guessing based off of two examples who were both Thanos. But Tony didn't reverse Thanos' snap, Bruce did. Marvel's just dropped some important clues suggesting the MCU villain is still alive. Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood, Latest Blog Post: The First Officer: Alpha Protocol Book 2, Favorite Question and Answers from Second Quarter 2023. After tossing orbiting moons and shattering eldritch duplicates, Thanos stabs Stark in the side before clenching the Gauntlet to deliver the finishing blow. How is it that in the Endgame Super Bowl TV spot everyone on Earth are mourning the dead if no one really died? RELATED: Doctor Strange 2 Warps WandaVision Into Something More Sinister Than a Tale of Grief. Tony could recall her name being mentioned then. For Thanos at the end of the movie, this is part of his Heros Journey, we once again put him face to face with the only thing that he cared about, where he has to own up to the emotional cost of what hes done in the movie.. Also, Tony was risk adverse to the whole time heist, and wanting to avoid risking his family. Thanos literally erased half the life in the universe - not just sentient beings, but half the plants, animals, and bacteria as well. As evidence, the Redditor offers the fact that the decimation begins in New York soon after the attack on Wakanda starts. Why: He used his Infinity Gauntlet containing all the Infinity Stones to snap once more and it took a toll on him, but that second snap didn't dust the remaining half of the universe's. That in turn means there's no reason someone couldn't successfully work out how to bring Thanos himself out of this cosmic cold storage. : r/marvelstudios When Tony stark had all the six stones, he was literally the most powerful being in the Universe. For more information, please see our I think smart Hulk would have figured it out eventuality. With Captain Marvel having destroyed Thanos' flagship, the Terrans seemed to get the upper hand on their own, and still Tony chose to sacrifice himself. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. However, it is more likely based on the evidence that Strange knew Thanos would keep his word and spare Tony's life, which would mean that he would have had to make an exception when he executed the Snap, singling out Tony specifically and therefore breaking the beauty of his plan. Why does the present continuous form of "mimic" become "mimicking"? The question is, then, what did the two snaps actually do? The Mad Titan believed that explosive population growth threatened to result in a universal extinction-level event. and our This energy pattern is stored in a memory buffer, then transmitted to another point, where it is converted back into matter. Then, she gets an alert (undoubtedly from SHIELDs ops center) that the Mad Titans fleet of ships were only just then entering the atmosphere over Wakanda to start the attack on Wakanda. Shockingly, Thanos proved to be the one villain who truly succeeded in his goal, and inAvengers: Endgame, he died content. You don't have to kill Thanos, you already did that. He confirmed his suspicions that one of his other children, Black Maw, was dead before speaking to his vision of the universe. He's the creator and author of Collider's "How the MCU Was Made" series and has interviewed Bill Hader about every single episode of Barry. This means Strange considered two different possibilities. Why did Tony Stark keep the electromagnet in his chest? Tony knows he is going to die, and also knows that is the only way to end the game. Next: Infinity War's Biggest Question Is What Endgame DIDN'T Show, Avengers: Age of Ultron Foreshadowed Thor's Infinity War Failure, Those who vanished as a result of Thanos snap, Infinity War's Biggest Question Is What Endgame DIDN'T Show, Yellowstone's Kevin Costner Exit Drama Threatens To Destroy The Show's Ending, "Over The Moon": Chris Evans' Brother Recalls MCU Star's Sweet Reaction To His Barbie Casting.
Army Reserve Retirement Points,
Articles W
why did tony's snap only kill thanos
